During a recent episode of his New Heights podcast with his brother Jason Kelce, Travis shared his love for several of Swift’s songs, including “Cowboy Like Me,” which he confessed he had fallen for after watching Swift perform it during her Tiny Desk appearance.

When asked which Taylor Swift song he would choose to listen to for the rest of his life, Kelce rattled off several favorites, including “Blank Space,” which he describes as a track he could always listen to, “forever.”

He also praised “Death by a Thousand Cuts,” calling it a song he’s learned to “absolutely love.” But it was Swift’s performance of “Cowboy Like Me” on the Tiny Desk that really caught his attention, further cementing his appreciation for her music. He also shared his admiration for “All Too Well,” calling it another standout track.

The 35-year-old Kansas City Chiefs player wasn’t shy about his love for Swift’s entire catalog, but he kept it lighthearted by admitting that his go-to favorite would always be “I Can’t Do It Without a Broken Heart,” joking that it’s the one song that stands out above the rest.

This revelation about his musical preferences comes as Kelce has been busy with the Chiefs, leading the team as they chase a third consecutive Super Bowl title. Meanwhile, Swift is on the final leg of her Eras Tour, performing in Canada, and the two have not been seen publicly together since the Chiefs’ victory over the Denver Broncos on November 10th.

During this time apart, it appears that Swift continues to occupy Kelce’s thoughts, as fans noticed a Swift-related slip-up during the New Heights podcast. In a segment where the Kelce brothers review films, Travis mistakenly almost referred to The Sisterhood of the Traveling Pants as Tortured Poet’s Department, which is the title of Swift’s latest album Midnights. He quickly corrected himself, but fans were quick to spot the mistake, and the slip-up sent Swifties into a frenzy.

Fans on social media couldn’t help but gush over the accidental mention, with many commenting on how heartwarming it was to hear that Swift is always on Kelce’s mind. “He has her album on his mind, it’s so heartwarming,” one fan commented on X (formerly Twitter). Others wrote, “Taylor is always on his mind, and it’s absolutely adorable.”

The slip-up has only fueled rumors that Kelce’s relationship with Swift is still going strong, with Swifties now convinced that the NFL star is not just a fan of Taylor’s music, but also of her presence in his life. Kelce, known for his easygoing and charming personality, continues to provide a window into his life and relationship with the global superstar through his podcast, which fans are loving for its candid and heartwarming moments.

In the meantime, it seems that Taylor Swift’s music will continue to be a prominent part of Kelce’s life—whether on his playlist or in his subconscious. With the release of Tortured Poet’s Department and his ongoing support of her musical journey, it’s clear that their bond continues to grow, much to the delight of their fans.